Layla Moran, the Liberal Democrat MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, used Prime Minister’s Questions on Wednesday 18 November to ask Andy Burnham to extend the ban on non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) to every victim of harassment, discrimination and bullying. The Prime Minister replied that “we will do exactly what she says”.

Overview

  • What she asked: a meeting with the Prime Minister to close what she called a “glaring loophole” that still lets freelancers and members of the public be silenced by NDAs.
  • What he said: the Government will “go further”, will “look at freelancers” and “will do exactly what she says”.
  • What she wants: a rule making it unlawful for lawyers to negotiate or draft confidentiality clauses that hide harassment, discrimination or bullying in any civil case.
  • The Oxford link: her campaign began in 2018 with University of Oxford students who had been silenced by gagging clauses.

Where it started: Oxford students in 2018

Her office says that in 2018 young women from the University of Oxford came forward after they were sexually assaulted and then silenced by gagging clauses. Ms Moran worked with them and with campaigners including Zelda Perkins of Can’t Buy My Silence to bring in a ban on that use of NDAs in higher education.

She has since worked cross-party to extend the protection, most recently to workers through the Employment Rights Act 2025, which restricts the misuse of NDAs and confidentiality clauses in the workplace.

The question in the Commons

In the chamber, Ms Moran said:

“Nearly ten years ago, brave young women at Oxford University told me they’d been sexually assaulted in their colleges, only to then be silenced by gagging orders supposedly protecting them.

“Now these shameful agreements are rightly illegal in Higher Education, and I commend this Government for extending that ban to workplaces, although I would urge them to speed up.

“But there is a gaping loophole.

“Even with these new laws, freelancers and fans, like those targeted by Russell Brand, can still be silenced, and it has to stop.

“Will the Prime Minister meet with me to discuss how we extend this protection to everyone, so the rich and powerful can’t buy the silence of the vulnerable anymore, anywhere?”

The Prime Minister replied:

“I know she’s worked closely with the First Secretary on these issues and she speaks very highly of the very effective work she’s done.

“NDAs should never be used to silence victims… We never want to see powerful men using the law to silence accusers.

“We’ve taken action in the Employment Rights Act, but the First Secretary has assured me we will go further, we will look at freelancers, and we will do exactly what she says.”

The exchange can be watched on Parliamentlive.tv, from 12:44:03.

Who the current laws leave out

In a letter to the Prime Minister sent after PMQs, Ms Moran lists the laws passed so far, each covering one group:

  • the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023, for staff, students, members and visiting speakers of universities;
  • the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024, for victims and direct witnesses of crime;
  • the Employment Rights Act 2025, for employees.

“These efforts have been piecemeal, only outlawing the malpractice one section of society at a time,” she wrote. “They have been too slow and too many people are left unprotected.”

She cites Zelda Perkins of Can’t Buy My Silence, who has said that most of the women silenced by NDAs in connection with Russell Brand would not have been protected by existing or upcoming legislation, because they were freelance workers or members of the public.

Her proposal: treat it like fraud

The letter asks the Government to make it unlawful for legal practitioners to negotiate or write confidentiality clauses that hide harassment, discrimination or bullying in any civil case. Ms Moran points out that a similar duty already applies to fraud: under Solicitors Regulation Authority rules, lawyers may not make agreements, draft contracts or use NDAs that facilitate, hide or suppress known fraud or wrongdoing.

“It is impossible to argue that harassment, discrimination, and bullying are any less worthy of this protection,” she wrote. “If NDAs could never be drafted in cases of harassment, discrimination, or bullying, no victim could be silenced in this way again.”

She adds that the change would mean lawyers “are no longer left with the moral dilemma of choosing between pressure from above and their duty to the court.”

What she has asked the Government next

The letter thanks the Prime Minister for his answer and puts three requests to him:

  • to set out how, and when, the Government intends to extend the ban to freelancers;
  • an assurance that it will also look at extending the protection to all members of the public, since his answer mentioned only freelancers;
  • to consider her proposal to stop legal professionals ever drafting NDAs that conceal harassment, discrimination or bullying in any civil case, “so the law is never again weaponised against a victim.”

Ms Moran’s constituency office is at Grange Court, Abingdon Science Park. Earlier this autumn she wrote to the Chancellor about Oxford station and the maternity unit.

Source: Office of Layla Moran MP.